focus on
-
Tempo medio di lettura 5'

Why certify an employment contract? Obligations, benefits, and how to challenge it

Pubblicato in: Employment law
di Debora Teruggia
Home > Why certify an employment contract? Obligations, benefits, and how to challenge it

The certification of employment contracts is a legal mechanism that offers greater security and stability in employment relationships, reducing the risk of litigation and sanctions. Introduced by Italian Legislative Decree No. 276/2003, it allows employers and employees to obtain official recognition of the contractual classification, making it enforceable against third parties, including regulatory bodies such as the Italian Social Security Institute (INPS) and the Revenue Agency.

In addition to shielding the employer from potential reclassification of the employment relationship, certification ensures transparency and protection for employees by preventing arbitrary interpretations of contractual clauses. In some cases, certification is even mandated by law. But what types of contracts may be certified? What are the tangible benefits for companies and workers? And how can a certified contract be challenged?

Why certify an employment contract?

The certification procedure for employment contracts, governed by Articles 72–80 of Italian Legislative Decree No. 276/2003, is a voluntary process whereby the parties – namely, the employer and the employee – jointly request a third-party to formally assess and certify the classification, terms, and conditions of a contract.

The application for certification may be submitted either at the time of execution or at a later stage of the employment relationship. This flexibility allows the parties to adapt the contract to any organizational or regulatory changes, thereby preventing future disputes.

A key advantage of certification lies in its retroactive effect: if the Certification Commission determines that the contract has been implemented from the outset in accordance with its certified terms, the validation will cover the entire preceding period. In other words, certification strengthens legal protections for both parties and stabilizes the employment relationship.

Finally, a certified contract is enforceable against third parties: the Labor Inspectorate (ITL), INPS, INAIL, and the Revenue Agency may not challenge its classification or adopt contrary measures unless a judicial ruling intervenes.

Benefits of certification

Certification is issued by authorized Certification Commissions, which assess whether the contract complies with applicable laws and regulations. Should the contract be inconsistent with legal requirements, it must be amended before certification can be granted.

For employees: increased transparency and legal security

  • Greater clarity regarding contractual terms, minimizing the risk of arbitrary interpretations.
  • Enhanced legal protection in the event of disputes, through a contract with certified legal status.
  • Reduced litigation risk, as certification definitively establishes the nature of the employment relationship.

For employers: legal protection and strategic advantages

  • Lower risk of penalties and inspections, since a certified contract cannot be disregarded by oversight bodies without a court ruling.
  • Legal certainty and stability, avoiding arbitrary reclassification of employment relationships.
  • Enhanced corporate reputation, demonstrating transparency and regulatory compliance to stakeholders, clients, and investors.

In addition to its protective function, certification serves as a strategic tool that allows companies to consolidate their organizational models and mitigate their exposure to potential disputes.

Which contracts can be certified?

Initially limited to contracts of subordinate employment, certification has gradually been extended to all types of contractual arrangements (Article 75 of Legislative Decree No. 276/2003), including:

  • Self-employment and collaboration agreements;
  • Internships and traineeships;
  • Contracts for services and subcontracting;
  • Franchise agreements;
  • Specific contractual clauses, such as non-compete agreements, secondment arrangements, and job modification agreements under Article 2103 of the Italian Civil Code (including demotion agreements under Article 3(1) of Legislative Decree No. 81/2015).

When is vertification mandatory? Although certification is generally voluntary, it becomes mandatory in certain instances. For example, in contracts for services or subcontracting related to work performed in confined spaces or areas suspected of contamination, certification is a legal requirement. Failure to obtain certification in such cases may expose the employer to criminal liability.

A recent memorandum issued by the Labor Inspectorate (No. 694 of January 24, 2024) clarified that certification pertains solely to the employment contracts of personnel engaged by the contractor, not to the service contract itself. The Inspectorate emphasized that “if the legislature had intended to require certification of the service contract, it would have expressly done so, as it has for subcontracting agreements.

Can a certified employment contract be challenged?

Although certification renders a contract enforceable against third parties, it may still be challenged – albeit only under specific circumstances and through a defined procedure.
Any party – including the employee, the employer, or social security entities – wishing to contest a certification must first attempt a conciliation before the same Certification Commission that issued the certification.

A challenge is permissible only in the following cases:

  • Defects in consent (e.g., if a party was induced to sign through fraud or misrepresentation);
  • Incorrect classification of the contract, meaning the certification does not reflect the true nature of the relationship;
  • Discrepancies between the certified contractual program and its actual implementation.

Only if the conciliation attempt fails may the party bring the matter before the Labor Court, which will have final authority on the validity of the certification.

The certification of employment contracts is a strategic legal tool that ensures stability, transparency, and legal protection. While it remains a voluntary process, its use is increasingly widespread and recommended, particularly in employment contexts that are vulnerable to disputes.

With the support of a labor law attorney, the certification process can be tailored to meet the specific needs of both the employer and the employee, ensuring contracts that are more secure, transparent, and compliant with current legal standards.

© Canella Camaiora Sta. Tutti i diritti riservati.
Data di pubblicazione: 8 Aprile 2025

È consentita la riproduzione testuale dell’articolo, anche a fini commerciali, nei limiti del 15% della sua totalità a condizione che venga indicata chiaramente la fonte. In caso di riproduzione online, deve essere inserito un link all’articolo originale. La riproduzione o la parafrasi non autorizzata e senza indicazione della fonte sarà perseguita legalmente.

Debora Teruggia

Laureata presso l'Università degli Studi di Milano, praticante avvocato appassionato di Diritto del Lavoro e Diritto di Famiglia.
Leggi la bio
error: Content is protected !!