Disputes between startup shareholders: who owns the ideas and software?

Tempo di lettura: 12 minuti

Abstract

A founder develops software, joins a startup and receives shares in the company. But who actually owns the technology? And what happens when relations between the founders break down? This article examines the distinction between intellectual property ownership and shareholding, the circumstances in which an assignment or a licence may be appropriate, and the contractual arrangements that can prevent disputes and safeguard the company’s future.

Innovative ideas and shareholder disputes: the intellectual property dilemma

In the startup ecosystem, even the most innovative ideas can become a source of conflict. Disputes arise particularly when founders disagree over who genuinely contributed to the success of a venture and who is entitled to claim rights in the resulting intellectual property.

Consider, for example, a minority shareholder who conceived the original idea and made a decisive contribution to developing the project, but whose working relationship with the company was never formally established. If relations between the shareholders subsequently deteriorate, that individual may have to establish the extent of their contribution and, more importantly, which rights they actually own.

The difficulty is that originating an idea does not necessarily confer ownership of the rights to exploit it. Ideas, in themselves, do not always qualify for legal protection. The relevant questions concern what has actually been created and which forms of intellectual property protection may apply.

Copyright law (Italian Law No. 633/1941) and the Italian Industrial Property Code (Legislative Decree No. 30/2005) provide distinct forms of protection depending on whether the subject matter is, for example, a creative work, computer software, a patentable invention or a trade mark.

The legal position becomes particularly complex where the shareholder responsible for an innovation is not an employee of the company and no agreement governs ownership of the resulting intellectual property.

In such circumstances, the relevant rights may vest in the shareholder, the company or several parties, depending on the nature of the intellectual property, the contributions made and the contractual arrangements in place. The distribution of shares in the company is therefore insufficient, in itself, to determine ownership of what has been created.

To prevent these uncertainties from developing into legal disputes, it is essential to establish from the outset who is responsible for creating each asset, who will own the corresponding rights and how those rights may be exercised.

This is one of the purposes of agreements between shareholders: not merely to regulate their participation in the company, but also to prevent disputes concerning what may constitute its most valuable assets.

The following sections examine these issues in greater detail.

Does software developed by a shareholder belong to the shareholder or the startup?

Suppose one of the founders has developed the software on which the startup’s entire business depends. They may have spent months working on it, even before the company was incorporated. Other founders subsequently joined the venture, initial funding was secured and the product was eventually launched.

At that point, who owns the software: the shareholder who created it or the company that uses it?

The answer depends not on the distribution of share capital, but on the legal relationship within which the software was developed and any relevant contractual arrangements.

Being a shareholder is not the same as being an employee. Nor does becoming a shareholder automatically entail assigning the rights in something previously created.

Original computer software is protected by copyright from the moment of its creation, without any requirement for registration. Formal deposit may help establish the software’s existence and the date on which it existed, but does not, in itself, determine who has acquired the economic exploitation rights.

Where the software predates the company’s incorporation, its development history must therefore be reconstructed. Who wrote the code? What resources were used? Did anyone else contribute to its development? Were any copyright assignments or licensing agreements executed?

Describing software as founder-developed does not necessarily establish that the founder owns it exclusively. Other programmers, employees or external contractors may have contributed to its creation, and their respective legal positions must be examined.

The position differs where the shareholder is also an employee of the company.

Under Article 12-bis of the Italian Copyright Act, where an employee creates a computer program in the course of performing their duties or following instructions given by their employer, the exclusive economic exploitation rights belong to the employer, unless otherwise agreed.

This does not mean that the employee ceases to be the author of the program. Authorship and ownership of the economic exploitation rights remain legally distinct matters.

But what if the software was developed by an independent contractor?

The analysis becomes more complex, because it is necessary to establish precisely what was commissioned and which rights the client acquired.

In the case of self-employed work falling within the scope of Article 4 of Italian Law No. 81/2017, the rights in original contributions generally belong to the self-employed professional, unless the inventive activity forms part of the contractual assignment and is specifically remunerated as such.

However, it would be incorrect to conclude that software invariably belongs to its developer in the absence of an express contractual provision. Equally, payment of an invoice does not necessarily mean that the client has acquired every right in the program.

The contract, the purpose of the engagement, the nature of the contributions and the surrounding circumstances must all be considered.

Software, moreover, is not necessarily a single, indivisible asset. It may incorporate bespoke code, modules previously developed and used by the programmer, and third-party components, including open-source libraries.

A further distinction is equally important: receiving a copy of the source code does not automatically confer ownership of the underlying rights. Conversely, holding the economic exploitation rights does not, by itself, guarantee actual possession of all the source code required to maintain or modify the program.

For a startup, establishing this chain of rights is far more than a matter of administrative formality. It is essential to determining whether the company is legally entitled to use, modify and commercialise the technology on which its business depends.

The worst possible time to discover uncertainty over software ownership is when an investor asks the company to demonstrate that it holds the rights in its core technology.

Can i receive shares while retaining ownership of my software?

Yes. It is possible to become a shareholder in a startup while retaining ownership of the software one has developed. However, the parties must establish from the outset precisely what is being made available to the company and what is being received in return.

An arrangement expressed simply as “I provide the software and you give me shares” may appear straightforward. From a legal perspective, however, it can involve substantially different transactions.

The first option is an assignment of rights. Under this arrangement, the shareholder transfers to the company the economic exploitation rights identified in the agreement. Pursuant to Article 110 of the Italian Copyright Act, the transfer must be evidenced in writing. The shareholder remains the author of the program but does not necessarily retain the right to exploit it commercially (Articles 20 and 22).

A second option is a contribution to the company’s share capital. The software, or more precisely the rights relating to it, may be contributed to the company in exchange for shares or an equity interest. In the case of an Italian limited liability company (società a responsabilità limitata, or S.r.l.), however, the rules governing contributions in kind and their valuation must be observed, as provided by Articles 2464 and 2465 of the Italian Civil Code. Assigning a monetary value to an idea is not sufficient: the rights being contributed must be precisely identified and valued in accordance with the applicable legal requirements.

A third possibility is a licensing arrangement. The shareholder retains ownership of the software while authorising the startup to use it under agreed conditions. The agreement should specify its duration, whether the licence is exclusive, who may modify the software, whether sublicensing is permitted and who may access the source code. Above all, what happens if the shareholder decides to leave the company? Where a licence is intended to constitute a contribution to share capital, its admissibility and valuation must also be assessed.

There is, however, a further distinction that should not be overlooked: owning software and having the authority to decide how it is used are not necessarily the same thing.

A founder might transfer their technology in exchange for a 10% equity stake, only to discover that they have no effective influence over the company’s most significant decisions concerning that technology.

This is why intellectual property arrangements must be considered alongside corporate governance. In Italian limited liability companies, Article 2468(3) of the Civil Code allows particular shareholders to be granted special rights concerning the management of the company or the distribution of profits.

The articles of association, shareholders’ agreements and software-related contracts must therefore be aligned, particularly where decisions concern the sale of technology, the granting of exclusive licences or the admission of new investors. This is a central consideration in startup investment agreements and corporate governance arrangements.

Ultimately, negotiating the percentage of shares to be received is not enough. It is equally important to understand which rights are being transferred and how much control the creator intends to retain over the technology they have developed.

Can a departing shareholder take the software and compete with the startup?

Suppose relations between the founders break down. The shareholder who originally developed the software decides to leave. Can they reclaim the program? Prevent the startup from continuing to use it? Or establish a competing business?

The answer depends on the rights they have retained and the contractual obligations they have undertaken.

Where the shareholder has assigned the relevant software rights, leaving the company does not automatically restore ownership. Where a licence has been granted, its duration, terms and potential grounds for termination must be examined. In any event, a dispute between shareholders does not, in itself, justify deleting code, restricting access to systems or disrupting the provision of services.

But is a departing shareholder entitled to compete with the startup?

The answer requires a distinction between the different legal capacities in which that person may have acted.

Merely holding shares in an Italian limited liability company does not, in itself, give rise to a general prohibition on competition. The position may differ where the shareholder is also a director, an employee or a party to specific contractual restrictions.

For company directors, regard must be had to the duties arising from their office, conflicts of interest and any associated liability. The statutory prohibition on competition applicable to directors of Italian joint-stock companies (società per azioni, or S.p.A.) under Article 2390 of the Civil Code cannot automatically be extended to every shareholder of an S.r.l. The 2026 legislative reform also introduced Article 2390-bis of the Civil Code, addressing the use of information and business opportunities acquired in the performance of directors’ duties (Legislative Decree No. 47/2026, Article 9).

Where the shareholder is also an employee, they are bound during the employment relationship by the duty of loyalty laid down in Article 2105 of the Italian Civil Code. Any restriction on competitive activity after termination of employment must comply with the requirements of Article 2125 of the Civil Code, including the provision of financial consideration.

An important qualification remains: the freedom to engage in competition does not confer an unrestricted right to use the company’s software code, confidential information or trade secrets.

Accordingly, arrangements governing relationships between founders should address software ownership, confidentiality obligations, any restrictions on competition and the consequences of a shareholder’s departure as distinct legal matters.

Parting ways with a co-founder can be difficult. Discovering that their departure may also jeopardise the technology on which the entire business relies can be considerably more serious.

What should be examined before an investment or a shareholder dispute?

As long as relationships between shareholders remain constructive, many legal questions may appear to be of secondary importance. When an investor becomes involved, however, or a dispute arises, verbal assurances are no longer sufficient.

It becomes essential to establish which assets and rights genuinely belong to the company, which rights remain with individual shareholders and who is legally entitled to continue using the technology.

Five practical enquiries provide a useful starting point:

  1. What has been created, and by whom? The development history of the project should be reconstructed by examining code versions, technical documentation, patents, trade marks and individual contributions. It is particularly important to distinguish assets created before the company’s incorporation from those developed subsequently.
  2. Which rights have been transferred to the company? Employment contracts, consultancy agreements, assignments, contributions to capital and licences should all be reviewed. This assessment must also take account of components developed by third parties and any applicable open-source licensing conditions.
  3. Who can actually use and modify the software? The availability of source code, repositories, access credentials and the technical documentation required for maintenance should be verified. Holding the rights in a computer program does not necessarily mean possessing everything required to operate and maintain it.
  4. Who has decision-making authority, and what happens when a shareholder leaves? The articles of association, shareholders’ agreements and technology-related contracts must be mutually consistent. The consequences of a share transfer, withdrawal, exclusion or termination of a working relationship should be clearly established.
  5. What if the dispute has already begun? Before taking action, it is necessary to identify the rights allegedly infringed, gather evidence through lawful means and assess whether urgent protective measures are required. Restricting access, deleting files or interfering unilaterally with IT systems may simply aggravate the situation.

There is also a statutory protection of which minority shareholders should be aware.

In Italian limited liability companies, shareholders who do not participate in management are entitled to obtain information concerning the conduct of the company’s affairs and to inspect the company’s books and documents relating to its management, including through trusted professionals, pursuant to Article 2476(2) of the Italian Civil Code.

This right can be particularly valuable when reconstructing the circumstances surrounding a dispute. It does not, however, automatically confer ownership of the software on the shareholder, nor does it authorise unrestricted access to the company’s IT systems.

It is precisely at this intersection that intellectual property protection meets the resolution of corporate and commercial disputes.

For the individual shareholder, the central question is which rights have been retained and which decisions they remain entitled to influence. For the company, the issue is whether it can continue to use and develop its technology even as relationships between its founders change.

Ideas may give rise to a startup. But it is the combination of clear agreements, enforceable rights and reliable evidence that enables a business to endure, even when its shareholders can no longer agree.

Data di pubblicazione: 21 Febbraio 2024
Ultimo aggiornamento: 3 Novembre 2026
© Canella Camaiora S.t.A. S.r.l. - Tutti i diritti riservati.

È consentita la riproduzione testuale dell’articolo, anche a fini commerciali, nei limiti del 15% della sua totalità a condizione che venga indicata chiaramente la fonte. In caso di riproduzione online, deve essere inserito un link all’articolo originale. La riproduzione o la parafrasi non autorizzata e senza indicazione della fonte sarà perseguita legalmente.

Avv. Arlo Cannela

Arlo Canella

Managing Partner dello studio legale Canella Camaiora, iscritto all’Ordine degli Avvocati di Milano, appassionato di Branding, Comunicazione e Design.

Leggi la bio
errore: Content is protected !!